Casting decisions in K-Dramas can make or break a show, and they often become the center of heated debates among fans. While some casting choices are universally celebrated, others spark controversy, dividing audiences and even leading to petitions, boycotts, and production changes. From idol actors taking lead roles to established stars being overlooked, here are some of the biggest casting controversies in the K-Drama industry.
1. Idol Actors Taking Lead Roles
One of the most persistent debates in K-Dramas is whether idols should be cast as lead actors. While some idols successfully transition into acting, others face criticism for their lack of experience or perceived lackluster performances.
Case Study: Ahn So-hee in Entourage
When former Wonder Girls member Ahn So-hee was cast in the Korean adaptation of Entourage (2016), backlash erupted. Many viewers felt her acting was stiff and unnatural, which contributed to the show’s overall poor reception. Critics argued that her casting was based more on her celebrity status than her acting ability.
Mixed Reactions: Rowoon in The King’s Affection
SF9’s Rowoon received initial skepticism when he was cast in The King’s Affection (2021). However, his performance ultimately won over many viewers, proving that idol actors can succeed with the right role and preparation. His case contrasts sharply with those who faced backlash, showing that talent and effort can shift public opinion.
2. Veteran Actors Being Replaced or Snubbed
Another recurring controversy involves established actors being replaced by younger or more commercially viable stars, sometimes against the wishes of fans and industry insiders.
Kim Jung-hyun in Time Controversy
Kim Jung-hyun’s sudden departure from Time (2018) due to health issues led to an unexpected casting shake-up. However, the controversy escalated when reports surfaced that he had exhibited cold behavior towards his co-star Seohyun. Fans debated whether he should have been cast in the first place, given his apparent struggles during filming.
Lee Joon-gi Replacing Song Joong-ki in Arthdal Chronicles 2
Fans were divided when it was announced that Lee Joon-gi would replace Song Joong-ki in Arthdal Chronicles: The Sword of Aramun (2023). While Lee Joon-gi is a respected actor, many viewers believed Song Joong-ki’s portrayal was crucial to the original series, leading to debates over whether the sequel would live up to expectations.
3. Controversial Recasts and Actor Withdrawals
Sometimes, actors drop out or are forced to leave productions due to scandals, health issues, or creative differences, leading to mixed reactions from audiences.
Seo Ye-ji’s Exit from Island
Seo Ye-ji was originally cast as the female lead in Island (2022) but withdrew after being embroiled in a scandal involving alleged gaslighting of her ex-boyfriend, actor Kim Jung-hyun. Her departure divided fans—some felt it was necessary, while others argued that her personal life should not impact her career.
Ji Soo’s Removal from River Where the Moon Rises
After being accused of school bullying, Ji Soo was dropped from River Where the Moon Rises (2021), despite already filming a significant portion of the drama. His role was recast with Na In-woo, who had to reshoot multiple scenes. The abrupt change disrupted the production but was widely supported due to the severity of the allegations.
5. The Controversy Over Han So-hee’s Casting in Gyeongseong Creature
Han So-hee’s casting in Gyeongseong Creature (2023) faced backlash when some fans questioned her ability to portray a historical character in a high-budget thriller. Given her relatively short acting career compared to other established actresses, critics argued that a more experienced performer should have been chosen. However, others defended her, pointing out her growing filmography and dedication to her roles.
6. Kim Seon-ho’s Return to Acting After Scandal
Kim Seon-ho, once a beloved K-Drama star, faced public scrutiny when a personal controversy surfaced in 2021. Although he stepped away from the spotlight for a while, his return to acting in Sad Tropics sparked debates on whether he should be forgiven or continue facing backlash. While his loyal fanbase supported his comeback, some viewers remained skeptical about his reinstatement in the industry.
Final Thoughts
Casting decisions in K-Dramas are rarely without controversy, as they often reflect larger industry trends and audience expectations. Whether it’s idol actors facing skepticism, veteran actors being replaced, or questionable pairings raising eyebrows, casting choices continue to spark debate among fans. While some actors prove critics wrong, others struggle under the weight of expectations.
More Kdrama Controversy
- Script Changes and Actor Replacements That Altered K-Dramas
- Overseas Backlash: When K-Dramas Offended International Audiences – Controversies That Sparked Global Debate
- Cultural Appropriation and Insensitivity in K-Dramas
- Propaganda Accusations in K-Dramas – How Political Themes Sparked Heated Debates
